Audra Russell (Audra)
Apr 29, 2026
★
★
★
★
★
We hired Caton's Plumbing to replace a single pipe connected to our boiler. Before the plumber, Chuck, arrived, our boiler was fully operational — no issues whatsoever. After he replaced the pipe, he informed us that our air scrubber was leaking. This was not the case before his visit.
When we turned on the heat the following day, none of the pipes were getting warm. We called for a second visit, and the office representative, Deborah, confirmed there would be no charge since the work was under guarantee.
When Chuck returned, he explained that flushing the boiler had sent sediment into the air scrubber, clogging it. He then insisted the scrubber had already been leaking prior to his visit and needed to be fully replaced — at our expense. To be clear: the scrubber was not leaking before he arrived. His own explanation confirmed that flushing the boiler caused the clog, yet he declined to take responsibility. He also informed us his rate was $199.80/hour, directly contradicting Deborah's assurance of no charge. Deborah later confirmed he should not have quoted us for this visit.
We paid nearly $1,000 for a pipe repair we cannot even verify was done correctly, because the boiler — which was fully functional before Chuck's first visit — still does not work.
Following this, a representative named Durrell called me to ask what happened. Rather than attempting to resolve the situation, he stated outright that he did not believe anything I told him and that he would go to bat for his plumber regardless of the circumstances. He suggested the entire issue stemmed from me "challenging Chuck's knowledge." Before we got off the phone, Durrell told me that a person named Bryan would call me right away to arrange a refund. That call never came.
The work left our boiler non-functional. A promise of no charge was contradicted by the plumber on site. A promise of a follow-up call was never honored. And when I raised these concerns, I was told I was not believed.
Based on our experience and the pattern we have since seen in other reviews, we cannot recommend Caton's Plumbing.
EDITED to respond to their reply:
Thank you for your response. A refund was issued today. However, the concerns outlined in my review stand, as the boiler was left non-functional following your plumber's visit and multiple commitments made by your office were not honored. I also want to note that your invitation to reach out is contradicted by the fact that your representative Durrell not only told me he did not believe anything I said, but instructed me never to call Caton's Plumbing again. I hope this serves as constructive feedback for how similar situations are handled in the future."