St Matthews Jewelers is a jewelry business serving Louisville, KY. St Matthews Jewelers provides custom jewelry design, watch repair, jewelry repair, engraving, and buys gold, silver, and platinum. Established in the early 1980s and locally operated, St Matthews Jewelers features service craftsmanship and a wide selection of estate and designer jewelry. The business replaces about 25 watch batteries daily and offers master hand and machine engraving.
Jeweler
Services
Services and categories listed for this business.
Custom Jewelry DesignWatch RepairJewelry RepairEngravingBuying Gold, Silver, and PlatinumEstate Jewelry Buying and SellingWatch Battery ReplacementMaster Hand & Machine Engraving
Billy and staff take care of their customers. We recently came in to look at wedding bands and Billy cleaned my fiance's engagement ring for free. Additionally, had a battery in my watch replaced and had it returned to me the next morning. This is the only jeweler I will shop at in town. If you wish to have a more personal experience and avoid the feel of big box diamond stores, go see Billy.
J
jbrown
Aug 26, 2024
★★★★★5.0
Fantastic company. Have done business with Billy for years and I’m never disappointed. From a custom made engagement ring and earrings, to watch and necklace repair, the work is always excellent and service exceptional. Highly recommend using St Matthews Jewelers!
T
Tod Schuermeyer
Jul 29, 2025
★★★★★5.0
Mr Lawson treats every customer in a fashion that makes you think you are the sole reason he is there! Knowledgeable, honest, and sincere, he will get what you are looking for, or fix what you broke. He, and his staff, remain honest... even if it means they lose a sale! That is the kind of integrity I need in a jeweler, and the reason that I don't go to anyone else... ever!
C
Christy Martin
Jul 2, 2024
★★★★★1.0
I took an expensive watch in for repair . Battery was replaced . It ended up not being the battery . I was within my one year warranty. I was told it would be sent out but that the repairman would not be happy since the warranty would be expiring soon . Jeweler never called me . I called . Owner of jeweler store could not report issue with watch or what was repaired . He requested I pick up my watch that day even after hours . He said I needed to do business elsewhere for repairs . When I picked up my watch it was not working . Needless to say — they did not standby their warranty and I believe I was lied to about my watch . It should be n...I took an expensive watch in for repair . Battery was replaced . It ended up not being the battery . I was within my one year warranty. I was told it would be sent out but that the repairman would not be happy since the warranty would be expiring soon . Jeweler never called me . I called . Owner of jeweler store could not report issue with watch or what was repaired . He requested I pick up my watch that day even after hours . He said I needed to do business elsewhere for repairs . When I picked up my watch it was not working . Needless to say — they did not standby their warranty and I believe I was lied to about my watch . It should be noted that I paid for a new battery even though it should have been free IF they followed their warranty policy . Why offer a warranty if one won’t uphold their own policy ? Have informed many people of this experience . Extremely disappointed .i see now they are not accredited by BBB either and per other reviews I wish I read them before I went here.
B
Brian Rechten
Oct 24, 2024
★★★★★5.0
When we moved to Louisville we got a recommendation to check out St Matthews Jewelers. We met Billy and Kelly and staffers and made a very nice purchase. We recently returned to have my wedding band stretched from a 9 to a 10.5. Another jeweler was hesitant to do it but Billy was quite confident he could accomplish the task. He did! My ring never looked better. He buffed out 46 years worth of scratches and it looks like it did moments after saying: “I do”
I encourage all reading this to give them a try.
You will be glad you did!
Want to leave a review?
Sign in to share your experience with this business.
Because this profile is not managed on RepairHit, the business may not respond directly to quote requests.
RepairHit can help connect you with other claimed local professionals who may be able to help.
Request a Quote
Tell St Matthews Jewelers what you need. Add a photo if it helps explain the job.
Thank you. No quote request was submitted.
RepairHit Support
Need help with a claim, listing, or account?